The Walking Dead : Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

It's like the writers don't even try.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

.... Someone doesn't understand how conception works.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

You're wrong they didn't use contraception.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?


-Someone doesn't understand how conception works...

-You're wrong they didn't use contraception.


(Slow Clap)

Fantastic..

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

I see you too have avoided the question. You must know I'm right.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

I actually thought you were making a pun and I was expressing my joy in slow clap.

My theory on Judith (and Carl) is that Dale was the father.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

^^^^ This. It's like the writers aren't even trying anymore.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

I'm so glad someone else spotted this

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Maybe it was immaculate conception....That would make her Jesus' daughter and God's grand daughter.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Are you serious? It's entirely possible. The child(Judith) was conceived before Shane was killed...

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Yh but that don't make sense.

Your telling me all that happened in 9 weeks?

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Weeks? It takes 9 months (give or take) for gestation.....

"This organism and derivative genetic material is restricted intellectual property."

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

He is trolling and you are hot (if that is your real pic).

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

It's Tatiana Maslani from Orphan Black.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Ding ding ding. I wish I looked like her! But I'm ok anyway.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Im guessing zombie shane got up, went to bang lori one last time. Then came back to the field to get Rick but Carl blew his head off.

Either "WE" f*<kin or "I'M" f*<kin- Bill Cosby

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Maybe that's what we're supposed to think. What if Shane faked his own death? What if THAT'S what Jenner whispered in Rick's ear.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

https://youtu.be/-wAPtL7v2Fk

Either "WE" f*<kin or "I'M" f*<kin- Bill Cosby

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

a great point.


i shake my damned head at these hacks.


they dont even know how human biology works ROFLMFAO


Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Good question and topic here: If a zombie had sex and got someone pregnant, would it be a normal baby or a zombie baby??
Does anyone know????

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

I would say he/she would behave like a normal human but would have urges to bite someone every now and then. Like a female hybrid could be laying comfortably next to her normal human boyfriend then all of a sudden bite a chunk out of his neck.


Either "WE" f*<kin or "I'M" f*<kin- Bill Cosby

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

I think Rick new he and Lori had not been intimate for some time so it had to have been Shane's. He counted the months and said... Yep its his.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Yeah but did the writers forget that Shane was dead before Judith was born? So how could she be his? Doesn't make any sense.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

lol what? of couse a man's child can be born after his death!?

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Prove it.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

are you inbred or just naturally dumb?

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

^^^ Can't prove it

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Still reelin' them in, I see!

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

I'm sorry your not making any sense, did you not see in season 1 when Lori and Shane was in the woods alone together. I'm sure before that they were intimate with each other, Rick is not stupid he knew Judith wasn't his baby.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?


did you not see in season 1 when Lori and Shane was in the woods alone together.


Yeah but that happened BEFORE Judith was born. How are you not getting this?

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Wouldn't boinking be one of the first things a couple would do when they reunite during an apocalyptic event? And if I remember correctly, Rick showed up very soon after Shane and Lori made cookies. Terrible writing. Cancel it.

Look to the cookie!

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

This show is pants. The zombies I can buy, totally believable, but expecting us to believe a dead Shane is Judith's dad? Just stupid.



´¨*¨)) -:¦:-
¸.•´ .•´¨*¨))
((¸¸.•´ .•´ -:¦:-
-:¦:-
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

^^^ Gets it.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

This is how you troll. But this is how you also contribute to ending the forums.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Zombie sperm.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

This is some weak trolling.

0/10 abysmal

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Mad because his favourite show doesn't make any sense.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Kirkman's bad writing fell into Lori's plothole, then the awful direction led to the delay of proper fertilization of her terrible acting.

Post deleted

This message has been deleted.

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Was this ever retconned?

Re: Plothole: How can Judith be Shane's if he died before she was born?

Great bump!

Post deleted

This message has been deleted.
Top