The Lord Of The Rings : LOTR vs Hobbit

LOTR vs Hobbit

No contest. The Hobbit wins.

Re: LOTR vs Hobbit

LotR wins. Hobbit was a complete betrayal of the book its based on.

"All you have to decide is what to do with the time that is given to you." -Gandalf

Re: LOTR vs Hobbit

I said the Hobbit wins.

Re: LOTR vs Hobbit

LOTR for movies. Never read the books.

Re: LOTR vs Hobbit

The Hobbit is a great book.
There was no need for the 3 bloated movies, however.

Re: LOTR vs Hobbit

There was no need for the 3 bloated movies, however.
I agree 100%. One Hobbit movie. One LoTR movie.

Administrator
"filmboards is a bold experiment in free speech and anarchy"
I GameBoy

Re: LOTR vs Hobbit

Lord of the Rings is three books though so keeping it as a trilogy made sense but it is when Jackson’s work started to become bloated and drawn out.

Re: LOTR vs Hobbit

LOTR, but we didn't need three movies. Two would have worked better imho.



Schrodinger's Cat walks into a bar, and doesn't. 😼

Re: LOTR vs Hobbit

The Hobbit wins by a country mile.

Hark! Harold the angel sings.

Re: LOTR vs Hobbit

U gots ta speek troof ta powwa.

Re: LOTR vs Hobbit

Overrated and overlong. I found both were tedious and tryhard.

Re: LOTR vs Hobbit

Your opinion is invalid.

Re: LOTR vs Hobbit

books or movies?

He cares about these helpless mortals?

Re: LOTR vs Hobbit

Movies.

Re: LOTR vs Hobbit

LOTR easily even though i am kinda bored of them now.

He cares about these helpless mortals?
Top