unaffiliated with imdb.com
Film and Television Discussion
Experimental and Avant-Garde
: When there are ambiguous elements in movies, whose interpretation...
When there are ambiguous elements in movies, whose interpretation...
3 years ago
(August 01, 2015 06:28 PM)
Member since September 2007
... is the correct one: The filmmaker's (assuming they reveal it in an interview or something) or the viewer's (they usually interpret while watching the movie, before watching/reading the filmmaker's interview)? Is it different when the movie in question has one ambiguous element and when the entire plot is ambiguous? Whatever the answers are, do they also apply to other works of art?
Re: When there are ambiguous elements in movies, whose interpretation...
2 years ago
(January 27, 2016 12:15 AM)
Member since May 2005
If a filmmaker left elements ambiguous, I'm sure it was with reason. Sometimes, the intent is to get you to think about the possible solution. Other times, it's because the filmmaker doesn't want you to get bogged down with specifics regarding plot and character, but rather experience the scene from a more emotional or "instinctual" viewpoint.