Mary and Max : how many stars would you give it?

how many stars would you give it?

I'd give it 4 1/2 out of 5.
amazing film.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

4 out of five. I really liked it, but it could have done without 15 minutes.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

I see I gave it 10 out of 10 stars. After a few weeks' distance from seeing the film I'd keep my grade right there.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

It was 80 minutes. You really think it would have been better at an hour and five minutes?

“Mankind are governed more by their feelings than by reason.” ~Samuel Adams

Re: how many stars would you give it?

i gave it 9 on 10 cause it'd make more impact than 10 on 10 on imdb :-p

otherwise 10 on 10 .....

Post deleted

This message has been deleted.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

3/10 I personally didn't find it special.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

Prolly nine out of ten. Beautiful, touching movie...

“Mankind are governed more by their feelings than by reason.” ~Samuel Adams

Re: how many stars would you give it?

I give it 7/10. It was charming and fun much of the way, but I thought it got overly sappy/corny/preachy towards the end.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

i agree. it was a good film. but there were too many gross parts that took away from the emotion. could have been better. 6/10

Re: how many stars would you give it?


Slut, I'm a little confused. Over on the 'Latter Days' board you said you were a mormon missionary. Now I know for a fact that mormons are not allowed to watch films that have violence or gross parts in them. As a matter of fact, alot of the movies you have listed on your board are films mormons would never watch. I guess we can agree that you'rer a big old bullsh$tter.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

hahahaha. mormons can watch any number of films. just like jews, muslims, atheists, catholics, agnostics, etc... anyone is free to choose what he/she wants to watch an to voice their opinion on it. :) :) :)

Re: how many stars would you give it?

8.5/10. Seriously an excellent film

...or something far more sinister?

Re: how many stars would you give it?

a 9.6 \ 10 its the most unique animated movie i've ever seen , nothing soar higher than it but The Man Who Planted Trees , and some of Hayao Mayazaki's works ..

Adam Elliot made a short film named Harvie Krumpet you should see it ..

Re: how many stars would you give it?

One billion stars! Without hesitation, loved it!

Re: how many stars would you give it?

7/10.

I appreciate the creativity, but the animation never felt right. Still, at least it isn't a third as depressing as Grave of the Fireflies.


We're OWL exterminators!

Re: how many stars would you give it?

1 out of 5

damn booring

Post deleted

This message has been deleted.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

I just watched it today and it is now one of my all time favorite animated movies. 5/5.


Mary and Max - 10/10
Buried - 9/10


OT

Re: how many stars would you give it?

So did I today. 9/10

Stop thinking about it and enjoy the movie

Re: how many stars would you give it?

10/10. Unforgettable film that is also very beautiful and touching.












"Life after death is as improbable as sex after marriage"- Madeline Kahn(CLUE, 1985)

Re: how many stars would you give it?

I wish I could give it a 9 out of 10, because that would bring it up the top 250 further, but in the end I had to give it my true rating, which is 10.

______________________________________

Rubbish! We don't want to be happy, we want to be famous!

Re: how many stars would you give it?

10/10

or

5/5 stars..

Every Day Above Ground Is A Good One.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

I gave it 7/10 stars.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

9/10

You let a wolf save your life, they make you pay and pay and pay . . .

Re: how many stars would you give it?

8/10

Re: how many stars would you give it?

I'd give it a hundred stars! This is the best film I've seen in a long time.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

A hundred.



Re: how many stars would you give it?

9/10

Re: how many stars would you give it?

9/10
i enjoyed it very much. really like the quirkiness and honesty of the characters.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

4/5... the ending was sooo touchiing :'( i've cut 1 star for the animation part (I felt I was watching a puppet show instead of an animated movie)

Re: how many stars would you give it?

I'd say 7.5 out of 10
Way to much pity in this movie for the two characters, and the fact that Mary wrote a whole book then destroyed it all was absurd and stupid. That's one of the bits that bought this movie down quite a bit in fact, then that following of the whole sherry thing..

Re: how many stars would you give it?

7/10

"Let us be crooked but never common"

Re: how many stars would you give it?

NO! MY STARS! It can have some old, you know, that greenery what's on the back end of carrots. That it can have. It is great, but MY STARS BOI.

Who busts the Crimebusters?

Re: how many stars would you give it?

7.5/10. It could have been more but it failed to show there's no hope in this hopeless world.

my vote history:
http://imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=27424531

Re: how many stars would you give it?

10/10.....truly amazing and beautiful film.
the only other movie i rated 10 is Kill Bill Vol.2 and Yeh Mera India

Re: how many stars would you give it?

10/10 stars. I loved it.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

I'm thinking 6 out of 10. Appreciate the creativity of the animation but not overwhelmed with the results. The story had its moments, but ultimately was not that engaging. I'll bump it up to 7 on the strength of the animation.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

9.5/10, not just one of the greatest animated features of all time in my book, but one of the finest movie pictures.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

9 out of 10.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

I watched it in 2010 and it was too down for me. 5 out of ten. Maybe I'll give it another try someday.




"I will not go down in history as the greatest mass-murderer since Adolf Hitler!" - Merkin Muffley

Re: how many stars would you give it?

9 out of 10 from me. That's the highest rating I have EVER given a movie and I'm a movie buff, 63 yrs old and seen a LOT of movies.

I generally avoid animated movies but seeing that Hoffman provided a voice I was curious about it.

Very few movies bring a tear to my eye but this one did, several times.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

8.1/10

------------
Top 50 Favorite Movies(UPDATE 4):http://www.imdb.com/list/dDDa_qSKRxw/

Re: how many stars would you give it?

3 1/2 out of 5.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

I would give 6.5 but since IMDB rating system is still a bit retarded I had to give 7. It's a lovely film and I enjoyed it.

Re: how many stars would you give it?

5/10 !
Top