Best and Worst : Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Which do you prefer?


IMO EOT wins. I'd take this under appreciated gem. Over that loud 2001 A Space Odyssey wanna be.


I am the Alpha and the Omoxus The Omoxus and the Omega

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Personally I prefer Interstellar, but Edge of Tomorrow is fantastic.

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Interstellar I gave a 10/10, Edge of Tomorrow an 8/10. But it was for different reasons; if I had to keep rewatching one it would be EoT.

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Edge of tomorrow 9.5/10 it has good rewatchability,i liked interstellar on first viewing second time not so much(7.5/10).

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Edge of Tomorrow ; by far.

-Edge of Tomorrow (2014) - 7/10 (within my Top 201 movies)
-Interstellar (2014) - 2-3/10 (could not finish it due to boredom and turned it off @ 2hr10min.)

----------
My Top 100-ish Movies of All-Time! = http://goo.gl/EYFYdz
----------

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar


Interstellar (2014) - 2-3/10 (could not finish it due to boredom and turned it off @ 2hr10min.)


How absurd. It has a fantastic ending. It's a shame you couldn't stick around for it. I guess you were to busy rating movies to actually enjoy one.





Just a guy in Texas who loves movies.

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Up

For Winners, Losing Inspires Them. For Losers, Losing Defeats Them

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

9 Edge 7 for interstellar it tries but doesnt get anywhere

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Seems like Edge is getting a lot of rewatchability points.


I am the Alpha and the Omoxus The Omoxus and the Omega

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Edge of Tomorrow

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Both movies I've only seen once, and I knew going in that it was a Chris Nolan film, so I knew it was going to be great, on the other hand Edge of Tomorrow was a delightful surprise. That said, you need a certain mindset to watch Interstellar and since Edge of Tomorrow is a little bit more fun (I agree with everyone) it is more re-watchable. So, Edge of Tomorrow for me.

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

I think Interstellar is a thousand times better (10/10). Edge is fun (8/10) - but no where near as powerful a movie experience.




Just a guy in Texas who loves movies.

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

That feels like an apples/oranges choice. I like both, but for different reasons. EOT has a lot of humor in it and I don't think there's one ounce of humor in Interstellar!

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Both movies are good but imo Interstellar is better.

For Winners, Losing Inspires Them. For Losers, Losing Defeats Them

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Edge of Tomorrow I give an 8.
Interstellar I give a 6.

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

These are completely different movies. So it's odd to compare, the only thing they have in common is they are sci-fi.

Interstellar is a drama based on real scientific theory.

Edge of tomorrow is a make believe action movie.

Both are very entertaining in their own way.

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

^indeed. It seems to me the op just wants to show how much he dislikes Interstellar

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar


^indeed. It seems to me the op just wants to show how much he dislikes Interstellar


Presumptuous are we not? I gave Interstellar a 7/10. Why are you so butthurt because I didn't like it as much as you? Just answer the question.


I am the Alpha and the Omoxus The Omoxus and the Omega

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

I said so judging from this short explanation for your choice, and I'm not at all butthurt haha

I'd take this under appreciated gem. Over that loud 2001 A Space Odyssey wanna be.


While I'm more in love with Interstellar, both films are exceptional in their genre. For Edge of Tomorrow I didn't watch the trailer or read anything about it before watching except that it's another sci-fi with Tom Cruise. It surprised me and I thoroughly enjoyed the film: quick-paced and very fun. Interstellar on the other hand is a beautiful film with very solid performances from the cast. I have never been so emotionally invested in a film for god knows how long.

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar


These are completely different movies. So it's odd to compare, the only thing they have in common is they are sci-fi.

Interstellar is a drama based on real scientific theory.

Edge of tomorrow is a make believe action movie.

Both are very entertaining in their own way.



Illustration: I like Grand Master Flash's The Message over Bruckner's 7th Symphony . I prefer Sarasate's Carmen Fantasy over both. I like Stevie Wonder's AS over all three. All different types and styles of music. Who says the films always have to be similar to compare the two?


I am the Alpha and the Omoxus The Omoxus and the Omega

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Interstellar

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Interstellar no question.

This is my design

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Interstellar, by a little bit.

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Edge Of Tomorrow,easily.

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Edge of Tomorrow for me. I found it to be both more interesting and exciting.

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

Edge of Tomorrow, I love the manga its based on called All You Need is Kill.

Re: Edge of Tomorrow vs Interstellar

edge
Top