Nocturnal Animals : A dish best served cold (spoilers)

A dish best served cold (spoilers)

So when did you, honestly now, realize the new painting was from Edward?

I absolutely adore this film. Waiting for some great pulp all year long and finally a film that totally delivers on so many levels.

Thank you Tom Ford.

10/10

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

Right now

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

From you. Thank you. And his revenge was subtle and psychological and haunting.

I liked this movie as well. I loved the performances not only by the leads, but also by the smaller roles. And the location of West Texas was perfect. Single Man was a favorite of mine too. I think Colin Firth's best performance. Yes, thank you Tom Ford.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)


And his revenge was subtle and psychological and haunting.

Only problem - his revenge was so subtle it wouldn't haunt a schoolgirl, let alone a tough nut art dealer living in a big house at the top of Hollywood Hills. Therefore it's not RE-VEN-GE - think again.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

Well, he couldn't kill her or imprison her like Oldboy. She already had guilt and emptiness. A schoolgirl would not be haunted by this. Only a lonely unloved woman who went a different direction than the one she started out in her youth and one who lost a great love by becoming some of the things she despised as she despised in her mother. It is hard to fathom that she could ever suffer living in this beautiful place and having all these beautiful things - that would be the hard part for most people to figure out. When he stood her up at the restaurant - that was the best part of the "revenge." I don't think she ever suffered as he did.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

Sure - if you find that little morality tale of yours satisfying, stick with it.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

Yeah, I like the movie. I liked Michael Shannon and Aaron Taylor Johnson's performances. I think one or both will receive Oscar nominations. I like the visual. I like the style and pace of the movie, and I like the art and casting. I like the allusion to Hitchcock and to the Coen Bros. I would see it again. Morality tale - I am not getting that much morality to this for me. She did what most young people do with relationships in their youth. The story within the story is what is electrifying, but the "outer" story is compelling too and both were told well.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

I also have a soft spot for nested stories and admire the film, although I have a very different interpretation from yours.
I used the term 'morality tale' because you implied Edward's 'revenge' was intentional, and it had worked to some degree. Personally I don't believe the Revenge aspect ever existed, and Susan fully understands this when she's sitting in the restaurant.
All this babble about her being forever crushed by Edward's non-appearance is the stuff of cheap melodrama. She's 40-something, beautiful, successful and about to receive a substantial divorce settlement. Don't worry about Susan, she'll get over Edward's no-show - especially if he's still alive.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

Keep trying pup.

Susan is crushed. Everything is falling apart in her life. She just found out her husband is cheating on her and was hoping to rekindle an old flame. She dresses up, takes off the ring, shows off the tats, she's ready for something special and then BAM!!!!!!! the truth sets in.

CRUSHED.

a dish served cold indeed.

Your lack of knowledge concerning Susan's emotional state shows a great distance between you and the film. No one has to actually what happens to Susan because most know exactly how she feels. but you seem to have no idea? Maybe you simply haven't been through a relationship like this? Your experience here is quite telling. It's quite virginal.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)


Susan is crushed. Everything is falling apart in her life.

Have to applaud Amy Adams - she looked soooo sad in that last shot. Very fine acting and it also serves as a great contrast to the opening scene with the big ladies.

Imperfect and happy vs. perfect and unhappy

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)


Imperfect and happy vs. perfect and unhappy

Well, she's going to be unhappy for about 6 hours at most. I've associated with female art dealers throughout my professional life, and they're made of sterner stuff than some old guy who thinks Susan will melt into a puddle of self-pity over this and the trifle of a broken marriage.
Do you think it's easy selling junk to narcissistic billionaires, while pandering to the egos of talentless artists who see themselves as superstars? Susan's profession requires SELF-BELIEF in spades - and Susan will put it to work for her before the sun rises. The character is based on dealers like Mary Boone, who eats naive old guys like you and me for breakfast. Believe me, I'd rather tangle with Ray and his pals than her and her ilk.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)


Well, she's going to be unhappy for about 6 hours at most.


I'm not sure what you mean, because she was unhappy all along (it's stated explicitly) and Edward made it worse, not so much with his no-show but rather because his novel made her see things differently and opened her up to a feeling of loss.

I would say that the scene where she stops and stares at the calf pierced by arrows is quite an obvious clue in this direction. Same with the synchronized bathtub shots and the scene where she suddenly goes soft in the board room and decides not to fire someone because "you shouldn't change things all the time".

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)


I'm not sure what you mean, because she was unhappy all along . .

I guess what I meant is she's not going to be "crushed" or "destroyed" as others have maintained by this dinner no-show - especially if she learns it was part of some pathetic revenge scheme.
OTOH I don't think she's going to learn any such thing. I believe Ford has managed to deceive most of his audience about Susan's character and Edward's motivations. I think she's going to discover Edward has passed on, and she'll be deeply sad about that.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

Farshnoshket, please stop assuming that tigerfish doesn't understand something because of their own real life. This movie is NOT remotely close to real life. Maybe in an extremely broad sense that people can become unhappy with their lives or people can use loss as a form of artistic inspiration, but Tom himself said that he adapted the original source material into a melodrama "for film" so it's intentionally not realistic.

If I were Susan I'd be sadder about the state of the rest of my life than being stood up by Edward. Then again, I don't see how reading a book by an ex is supposed to make you fall back in love with them (outside of a contrived movie plot).

But tigerfish, you're not being a great sport to them either, you guys can have a discussion without making it personal. If we can't play nice they'll take the boards away--oh, wait.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

Actually, they both will be fine. Edward, too, will have a successful book based on a doomed and painful relationship - but successful we are led to believe. Would he have had that without knowing Susan? We all should be so lucky,

Edward wanted to let her know that it was painful for him. He succeeded in his manuscript. Whether the affect really hit Susan hard isn't the question, but that it did do some awakening in her that she was now interested in him. He had the last word with the no-show and it really was enough for the end of their story.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

I suspect Edward will be fine too - although he's certainly dying, and quite possibly already deceased - as are both his alter egos in the novel: Bobby of cancer, and Tony from an accidental gunshot wound.
These two deaths can't be ignored. As in life, so in art - as in art, so in life.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

What? Edward is not dead or dying? No character is dead - just in the sub story. Maybe it felt like death to Edward and he had no say about their pregnancy - but I have no reason to believe that he's dying or that he he sent a manuscript and then died.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)


What? Edward is not dead or dying?

Sure - writers never use symbolism or allegory; the words have no actual meaning - just like the question mark at the end of your sentence; and your brain is wide awake.
Keep on believing all that, and you'll be just fine.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

Yes, I will be fine too. Tony died in Edward's manuscript but Edward is alive to write the manuscript and profit from it, as well as use it to enlighten Susan and turn the screw. This guy isn't going to commit suicide either.There is nothing about Edward dying In the book or in any of Tom Ford's interviews about this story. This character is alive and masterfully played Susan. In the sub story - yes, in West Texas, he fell on his gun. In the sub story, everyone dies - his wife, daughter, all the bad guys, and Tony and eventually the cop.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)


Yes, I will be fine too. Tony died in Edward's manuscript but Edward is alive . . .

Glad to hear it. And Ford probably got Gyllenhaal to play both Edward and Tony because he didn't have the cash to pay a second actor, right?

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

So, if Jake didn't play Edward - maybe 15 minutes of screen time, and went with Tony character - what actor would play.Edward? And then why would Jake accept just the part of Tony. You can't split these roles with two different actors? You would lose your star power. Susan is a main player - not Isla Fisher. Edward is an invisible main player. And then there's Tony....

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

Edward never actually appears in the primary world of the frame story. All scenes with either Edward or Tony are Susans' recollections and imaginings respectively. She is imagining Tony as Edward.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)


She is imagining Tony as Edward.

She's probably right to do so. Edward's arc in his real life corresponds to Tony's fictional one. Edward loses a wife and child, and succeeds as an artist by getting his work published, while Tony suffers a symbolically similar blow and becomes a man by slaying his demons.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

Yeah, she is. He's written himself into his own story and this is stated directly in the flashback. My point is that the film follows Susan for the entirety. You are shown a 3rd Person objective view of Susan in the present, flashbacks which are presented by device as her recollections in the present, and her imagined visualization of the manuscript's narrative. There is no 3rd person objective view of Edward. The Edward presented to the audience is via Susan.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

I agree with you. I also enjoyed the movie.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

Didn't her employee say she bought that some years back?

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

Which painting? The one that spelled "REVENGE"? Was it ever mentioned? I don't recall.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

it wasn't

i'm tired of dancing here all by myself

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

Everyone keeps reading into this film and keep trying to make Gyllenhall the lead character... Bit annoying.

Saw it again

Turns out the painting was actually bought by Susan, she just didn't remember.

Re: A dish best served cold (spoilers)

What new painting??????

Oh the revenge one in Susan's gallery?



#harshtruth
http://barbie-verified.tumblr.com/post/147223710383/
Top