The Invitation : The minute John Carroll Lynch walked in…

I thought, "Oh, there's the Zodiac Killer. Something really bad is gonna happen here." Unfortunately he did such a good job creeping me out in Zodiac that whenever I see him in a film, I think, "Oh, the Zodiac!" And here it actually made sense.

I had that feeling too! As soon as he walked in, I knew he was up to no good.

oh *beep* that's why he looked so familiar. I didn't recognize him right away but I knew I saw the actor somewhere else

He was also Marge Gunderson's husband in Fargo, the duck painter.

Ditto. I knew he'd be an enforcer type. There's even a great shot of him behind Will where it looks like he's got his arms around Will's neck.

Yes plus he was a bit too smooth and "culty", folding his hands carefully in front, etc.

Twisty the Clown in American Horror Story

Wasn't he drew Carey's brother in the drew carey show? I always picture him in drag haha