Arrow : They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

In Arrow of course. She has been on the CW before in Nikita, so it wouldn't be too difficult getting her on board.

Post deleted

This message has been deleted.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

No thanks. Katie Cassidy is perfect.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

No thanks. She's uglier than Katie Cassidy.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

I know beauty is in the eye of the beholder, but you need an ophthalmologist.

---
You're suffering from delusions of adequacy.
Cookies: http://tinyurl.com/hj7nl9j

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

Haha! No, it isn't. Beauty can be judged objectively, and Katie Cassidy is objectively hotter than Katheryn Winnick.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

In your reality perhaps.

---
You're suffering from delusions of adequacy.
Cookies: http://tinyurl.com/hj7nl9j

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

In everyone's reality.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

Nope, your reality





Do you mind if I have a piece of your thigh? It would complement this fine '76 Shiraz

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

Nope, objective reality. Have you seen that huge nose on Katheryne's face?

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

You know who has the best nose? Amy Adams. Her nose has a beautiful curve. I never thought a nose could turn me on soooooooooooooooooo much.

Of all the gin joints, in all the towns, in all the world, she walks into mine.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

I'm afraid I'm gonna have to agree with Mr MichaelSchoffield on this one. I don't watch Vikings or whatever show Katheryn is famous for and I'm sure she plays a beautiful character there but if we superficially compare the actresses based on looks then Katie wins hands down.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

Thank you! I'm not saying Katherine isn't a beautiful woman. I'd give my left nut to be with any of these women. But I think Katie has a perfect face. I'm astounded by her beauty more than that of any other woman. Especially by the way she used to look a few years ago before losing all that weight for season two of Arrow.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

You are right! OMG, Amy Adams has an amazing nose. The nose is usually the part that can ruin the face of many beautiful women, but Amy Adams has a perfect face.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

Someone buy this man a beer. No two. No a fùcking winery.

People always think i'm insane when i mention Amy's nose. As if its a strange fetish or something. I'm glad you understand!

Of all the gin joints, in all the towns, in all the world, she walks into mine.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

Haha! Thank you kind sir! You are much too generous.

I don't think it's insane at all. It's the part that can make or break a face. Amy's nose is just right, which is extremely rare in many people. I'm also glad to not be the only sees this.

Cheers mate!

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

Winnick looks like a woman, Cassidy looks like a tranny. There's no doubt Winnick is way hotter and talented.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

She's in her late 30's now (that's why she plays a mom of an already grown man on Vikings).

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

The ages of Vikings characters don't mean dick. They're all over the place.
Plus Katheryn looks phenomenal. She's only like 4 years older than Amell. She'd be fine had they cast her.

They all strive to deviate from the norm, but collectively swarm to be all the same.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

Name one female lead that was over thirty when cast on a CW show.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

AIsha Taylor, Krista Allen, Sara Michelle Gellar, Rachel Billson. Maggie Q and Peyton List by a few months.


They all strive to deviate from the norm, but collectively swarm to be all the same.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

As far as i know Aisha does a game show for the summer. The show with SMG only came to the CW after CBS decided against airing it on their main network. And the Buffy connection. Peyton List technically still under 30 when cast. We are talking about CW actually casting Kathryn Winnick who is 39 at this point. Even SA was under 30 when cast for this role. No show on the CW that is currently airing has cast a female lead over 30. There were the ones that are/were in 28-31 age demographic. But its just a sad fact that CW is looking for younger leads for their shows.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

Ah, Currently airing. Smart way to ignore the 40 something year old elephant in my post, Krista Allen.

They all strive to deviate from the norm, but collectively swarm to be all the same.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

What show was she on? Is she the female lead? Because with the way this show was set up BC was supposed to be the female lead.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

Significant Mother. Yes. It sounds terrible though.

They all strive to deviate from the norm, but collectively swarm to be all the same.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

She's too old for Black Canary, she is not supposed to be older than Green Arrow. Fine with Katie, and Katheryn is on Vikings.

-------------------------->
Arrow Time of death 11:59
RT #NoLaurelNoArrow
Long Live Laurel Lance

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

I think Yvonne Strahovsk would have been the far better pick if they had written her right. She is one year younger than Stephen Amell and is a trained martial arts expert in real life who did all her own stunts on Chuck. Don't get me wrong, I like Katheryn apart from that one weird role she did where her brother wanted to grow up and marry her and jumped up and down and said "boobies!" when he walked in on her with her boyfriend 😨😂but Hollywood and the TV industry are getting worse with ageism every year and would see her as being too old.

_____________________________

A note to homophobes: Don't hate me because of my sexuality...Hate me because you don't have the guts to accept yours 😄

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

Yvonne Strahovsk would have been perfect! Why haven't I thought about her before?

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

I don't know but I have thought she would be perfect for the role since she was in Chuck and I hope they use her in the upcoming DC/Warner Bros movies.

_____________________________

A note to homophobes: Don't hate me because of my sexuality...Hate me because you don't have the guts to accept yours 😄

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

Yup, I love Yvonne Strahovski, ever since I watched Chuck...repeatedly. She's a year younger than Mr Amell.

This sub-thread is reminding me of Emily Blunt, born 1983, so also not quite up to Mr Amell's antiquity.



~~~~~
Because supporting your thesis is tough, but throwing adjectives is easy.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

Not really on topic, but since it's a thread about Winnick it's kinda-sorta related.

These last two days I finally caught up on some of the shows I follow, to a grand total of about 10 hours of viewing pleasure.

For the most part, all of the episodes I watched had me begging for more. Production, writing, acting, everything on point - or at the very least at an acceptable level. Even the ones that had me worrying about where they are headed (e.g. Vikings) more than made up for it.

I can't say I ever felt like that for any of the Arrowverse shows, but at least in the past they were entertaining to watch. How the hell did it all go so horribly wrong that I am actually considering dropping some of them?

---
You're suffering from delusions of adequacy.
Cookies: http://tinyurl.com/hj7nl9j

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

I'm worried about Vikings. Characters like Rollo and Lagertha have stayed long past their welcome and Floki is getting tiresome with his "I'm in love with the Muslims but 5 minutes later chastise Rollo for not being a true Viking."

I hope it rebounds because I think it can set an important precedent for shows killing off their protagonist and continuing the story like I want Arrow and Flash to do, if they introduce a worthy Bart Allen or ginger Wally or out of left field Tornado Twins) Basically only Bjorn should be around from the old cast of Vikings (the people, not the show.)


They all strive to deviate from the norm, but collectively swarm to be all the same.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

Lagertha's arc will be over soon. As for Floki... he's the main reason I am concerned. In the last episode he was used as a vehicle for the showrunner (who is very open about his bias) to virtue signal regarding muslims, in a very out-of-character moment that some desperately try to excuse as him being more mature.

Rollo's arc is more or less done too, I believe, as he finds the place history has in store for him. Floki's words to Bjorn regarding him will come true, after all. That said, I think they did a fine job with Ragnar's sons. Each of them feels unique, and most of them have their father's charisma.

---
You're suffering from delusions of adequacy.
Cookies: http://tinyurl.com/hj7nl9j

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

What you said.

I just hope they find some way to give us a bit more of Lagertha.

I think Floki has not ceased to surprise us yet... Maybe another cruel decision to justify his death ? I don't like the way he looks at the girl they have adopted, just the way I'd look if I found a rat in my house : disgusted and angered. (I've been hating him ever since he killed Athelstan )

⚜ Lance is a Saint ⚜
http://youtu.be/PJ8ZL0wX9lo

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

Don't hold your breath on a Ginger Wally West taking over the show. You may get an Earth-Whatever Easter Egg, but that's it.

I'm Barry Allen & I'm the fastest man alive. Darn it Wally! I'm Barry Allen & I'm the 2nd fast...

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

I'm not holding my breath for any kind of major shakeup. These writers are too big of pussies to even make a paradigm changing development like Killer Frost change Caitlyn's standing on the show. They can't go 5 episodes without a Wells on the team.

They all strive to deviate from the norm, but collectively swarm to be all the same.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

Please withdraw your application to write for CW shows.



~~~~~
Because supporting your thesis is tough, but throwing adjectives is easy.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

My application? What are you on about? Support your thesis.

They all strive to deviate from the norm, but collectively swarm to be all the same.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

I did see a video of her talking about her real life martial arts skills and another older video before Vikings that shows clips from other shows and a commercial I think around 2005 though. She got her black belt at age 13 and even had her own MA school. She's more legit than even Caity Lotz just in those skills alone. It's too bad she can't use it on Vikings. The video I saw was back when she was on CSI NY. Back then her looks and skills would fit perfectly with the Black Canary character. She could have been Black Canary on Smallville but I guess they figured it was easier to get a Vancouver actress rather than a Toronto one. Having skills didn't matter on that show though - stunt doubles did it.

Re: They should get Katheryn Winnick to play Black Canary

She is very beautiful actress, so yes she has the looks to play Black Canary, but that is not the only thing, that has to be taken into account, when casting someone for a bad ass action hero.
Top