American Horror Story : With ranking the seasons…

With ranking the seasons…

I know we all love ranking the season. And everyone has list of favorites in order
( Asylum
Coven
Murder house
Roanoke
Freakshow
Hotel )

But comparing all the season is just like comparing apples and oranges, because they are all so different. I think that every season does have something to praise that we have a tendency to look over because each season is something so different.

Murderhouse- character development

Asylum- storytelling

Coven- campy/ humor

Freakshow- set design (it took me alot of time think of something special for this season (maybe I should move it down in my ranking))

Hotel- stylization

Roanoke- story/ setting


Any thoughts on what you think makes a season good?

Re: With ranking the seasons…

It's hard for me to rank the seasons because other than Freakshow and Roanoke it's hard for me to pick a favorite. I finally had to think of which show I had more favorite episodes. That helped.

Murder House
Asylum
Coven
Hotel
Freak Show
Roanoke

They all had expert storytelling, with the exception of Roanoke (IMO), it seemed more of an indictment on reality/re-inactment/fake-ghost hunters/b-list style horror etc. I know a lot of people loved it, just not my kind of escapism. Plus, visually I couldn't see what was going on half the time because it was so dark.

Re: With ranking the seasons…

My favorite to least favorite:

1. Freak Show
2. Coven
3. Murder House
4. Asylum
5. Roanoke
6. Hotel
Top